Wealth Without Strategic Autonomy: Chokepoint Vulnerability and Small-State Security in the Gulf

13 Jan 2027, 17:00

Description

This paper examines how regional conflict in the Middle East exposes a distinctive vulnerability for highly globalised small states i.e. dependence on secure movement through chokepoints and infrastructures they cannot fully control. I argue that wealth does not always produce strategic autonomy. Using Qatar during the recent 2026 Iran-US war as a focused case study, I make the case that fiscal resilience can coexist with logistical vulnerability. Qatar’s immense hydrocarbon wealth, sovereign assets, and state capacity enabled it to absorb shocks, but its development model remained dependent on secure circulation through Gulf airspace, and maritime energy transit via the Strait of Hormuz. When conflict disrupted these routes, vulnerability appeared less through territorial destruction than through interrupted flows of energy, passengers, aircraft, cargo, and capital. I develop the concept of chokepoint-dependent resilience to explain this condition. Methodologically, I use a qualitative case study model via process tracing across two domains i.e. aviation and LNG sea transit, primarily relying upon publicly available data on air and marine traffic, as well as official reports. The paper contributes to international security studies literature by showing how violence imposes costs on states beyond the battlefield through delay, uncertainty, reputational damage, and route dependence.

Speakers

Presentation materials

There are no materials yet.